doPhysics.in
All chapters

Combining Lenses: Contact, Gaps, Silvering and Cutting

15 min read4 ideas5 checks3 figures to playBy Asheshanand Acharya
What you will learn 0 / 4
Lenses in contact

Two lenses as one

Put two thin lenses in contact, on one axis. The first lens forms an image of the object. That image is the object for the second lens, at the same distance, since the lenses touch. Add the two lens formulas, and the combination behaves as a single thin lens.

Deriving \(\dfrac{1}{F} = \dfrac{1}{f_1} + \dfrac{1}{f_2}\) step 1 of 3
1

\[ \dfrac{1}{v_1} - \dfrac{1}{u} = \dfrac{1}{f_1} \]

Why. the first lens forms an image of the object at \(v_1\).

The combination has an equivalent focal length \(F\), and its power is the sum of the two powers, \(P = P_1 + P_2\). A convex lens of \(20\,\text{cm}\) and a concave lens of \(30\,\text{cm}\) in contact give \(\dfrac{1}{F} = \dfrac{1}{20} - \dfrac{1}{30} = \dfrac{1}{60}\), so \(F = +60\,\text{cm}\). In dioptres, \(P = 5 - 3.33 = +1.67\,\text{D}\).

RememberThin lenses in contact
\[ \dfrac{1}{F} = \dfrac{1}{f_1} + \dfrac{1}{f_2} + \dots, \qquad P = P_1 + P_2 + \dots \]
Holds whenthin lenses touching each other on a common axis, in air.
Symbols\(f_1, f_2\) focal lengths of the lenses; \(F\) equivalent focal length; \(P_1, P_2, P\) the powers
Units\(f, F\) in cm or m; \(P\) in D, with \(f\) in m

A convex and a concave lens of the same focal length cancel each other. For \(+20\,\text{cm}\) with \(-20\,\text{cm}\), \(P = 5 - 5 = 0\), and the pair acts as a flat plate of glass. Use the equivalent lens like any other. An object \(30\,\text{cm}\) from the pair of \(60\,\text{cm}\) gives \(\dfrac{1}{v} = \dfrac{1}{60} - \dfrac{1}{30} = -\dfrac{1}{60}\). So \(v = -60\,\text{cm}\): a virtual image on the object's side, with \(m = +2\).

Checkpoint · numericUnanswered

Two thin lenses in contact have a combined focal length of \(12\,\text{cm}\). One of them has a focal length of \(20\,\text{cm}\). Find the focal length of the other, in cm.

cm± 2 %
In the world
The optician's trial frame

At an eye test, the optician places lenses one behind another in a heavy trial frame on your nose. Each lens is marked with its power. A lens of \(+1.00\,\text{D}\) with one of \(+0.50\,\text{D}\) behind it makes \(+1.50\,\text{D}\), a lens of about \(67\,\text{cm}\). Because thin lenses in contact add their powers, the optician can try many powers with a small box of lenses. The prescription then records the total.

Lenses with a gap

Two lenses with a gap

Now pull the two lenses apart by a distance \(d\). The light that leaves the first lens reaches the second at a different height, and the second lens bends it by a different amount. The equivalent focal length then depends on the gap. \[ \dfrac{1}{F} = \dfrac{1}{f_1} + \dfrac{1}{f_2} - \dfrac{d}{f_1 f_2}, \qquad P = P_1 + P_2 - dP_1P_2 \]

RememberTwo thin lenses with a gap
\[ P = P_1 + P_2 - d\,P_1 P_2, \qquad \dfrac{1}{F} = \dfrac{1}{f_1} + \dfrac{1}{f_2} - \dfrac{d}{f_1 f_2} \]
Holds whentwo thin lenses on one axis, a distance \(d\) apart, in air; with \(d = 0\) it becomes the rule for lenses in contact.
Symbols\(d\) the distance between the lenses; the rest as for lenses in contact
Units\(d\) in m with \(P\) in D, or \(d\), \(f\) and \(F\) all in cm

Take a lens of \(20\,\text{cm}\) and one of \(30\,\text{cm}\), \(10\,\text{cm}\) apart. In dioptres, \(P_1 = 5\,\text{D}\), \(P_2 = 3.33\,\text{D}\) and \(d = 0.1\,\text{m}\). Then \(P = 5 + 3.33 - 0.1 \times 5 \times 3.33 = 6.67\,\text{D}\), and \(F = 1/6.67\,\text{m} = 15\,\text{cm}\). In contact, the same pair has \(P = 8.33\,\text{D}\) and \(F = 12\,\text{cm}\). The gap has weakened the pair.

Two convex lenses, together and apartTwo convex lenses on one axis: the first of focal length 20 cm, the second of 30 cm. A parallel beam of two rays comes from the left. With the chip in contact, the two lenses stand together and the beam meets 12 cm beyond them. With the lenses 5 cm apart, the first lens bends the beam towards its own focus F1, 20 cm away, drawn dashed, and the second lens bends it again, so it meets 10 cm beyond the second lens. With the lenses 10 cm apart, the beam meets 7.5 cm beyond the second lens. A readout gives the gap, the equivalent focal length F and the distance of the meeting point beyond the second lens. f1 F1 in contact, F = 12 cm, b = 12 cm
Fig 5.1Lenses of \(20\,\text{cm}\) and \(30\,\text{cm}\) in a parallel beam. Use the chips. The dashed lines show where the first lens alone would focus, at \(F_1\). The readout gives the gap \(d\), the equivalent focal length \(F\), and the distance \(b\) beyond the second lens where the beam actually meets.
Deeper

The equivalent focal length \(F\) is not measured from either lens. It is measured from a plane called a principal plane, which lies elsewhere. Where the beam meets is found by the image-as-object rule. With the gap of \(10\,\text{cm}\), the first lens aims the beam at a point \(20\,\text{cm}\) away, \(10\,\text{cm}\) beyond the second lens. That point is a virtual object, \(u_2 = +10\,\text{cm}\). Then \(1/v = 1/30 + 1/10\), so the beam meets \(7.5\,\text{cm}\) beyond the second lens.

Checkpoint · numericUnanswered

A converging lens of \(+20\,\text{cm}\) and a converging lens of \(+30\,\text{cm}\) stand \(5\,\text{cm}\) apart on one axis. Find their equivalent focal length, in cm.

cm± 2 %
The silvered lens

A silvered lens is a mirror

Coat one face of a lens with silver, so that it reflects. Light now enters the lens, reflects from the silvered face, and leaves through the lens again. It crosses the lens twice and meets the mirror once. So a silvered lens behaves as a single mirror whose power is the sum of all three. \[ P = 2P_L + P_M \]

Here every power is counted positive when it converges the light. For the lens, \(P_L = 1/f_L\). For the silvered face, \(P_M = -1/f_M\), where \(f_M\) is its focal length as a mirror on the Cartesian convention. A concave mirror has \(f_M < 0\), so its \(P_M\) is positive. A flat face gives \(P_M = 0\). The whole system is a mirror of focal length \(f = -1/P\): a concave mirror when \(P > 0\), a convex one when \(P < 0\).

RememberA silvered lens
\[ P = 2P_L + P_M, \qquad P_L = \dfrac{1}{f_L}, \quad P_M = -\dfrac{1}{f_M}, \qquad f = -\dfrac{1}{P} \]
Holds whena thin lens silvered on one face, with converging powers positive; \(f\) is the Cartesian focal length of the equivalent mirror.
Symbols\(f_L\) focal length of the lens; \(f_M\) focal length of the silvered face as a mirror; \(P\) power of the system; \(f\) focal length of the equivalent mirror
Unitspowers in \(\text{cm}^{-1}\) (or D with lengths in m); lengths in cm
A silvered lens is a mirrorA plano-convex glass lens of focal length 20 cm, silvered on one face, with the silvering hatched. With the first chip the curved face meets the light and the flat back face is silvered. A parallel pair of rays goes in, turns back at the silvering and comes out through a focus F, 10 cm in front of the lens: the lens acts as a concave mirror of focal length 10 cm. With the second chip the flat face meets the light and the curved back face is silvered. The rays now come back through F only 3.3 cm in front. Readouts give the power 2PL + PM and the focal length of the equivalent mirror. F 2PL + PM = 0.10 per cm f = −10 cm: a concave mirror
Fig 5.2A plano-convex glass lens of focal length \(20\,\text{cm}\), silvered on one face. Use the chips. A parallel pair of rays turns back at the silvering and meets at F. With the flat face silvered, F is \(10\,\text{cm}\) in front. With the curved face silvered, it is only \(3.3\,\text{cm}\) in front.

Take the plano-convex lens of \(f_L = 20\,\text{cm}\), silvered on its flat face. The flat mirror adds nothing, so \(P = \dfrac{2}{20} + 0 = 0.10\,\text{cm}^{-1}\). Then \(f = -\dfrac{1}{0.10} = -10\,\text{cm}\): the lens acts as a concave mirror of focal length \(10\,\text{cm}\). Silver the curved face instead, of radius \(10\,\text{cm}\). Seen from inside the glass it is a concave mirror, \(f_M = -5\,\text{cm}\), so \(P_M = 0.2\,\text{cm}^{-1}\). Then \(P = 0.1 + 0.2 = 0.3\,\text{cm}^{-1}\) and \(f = -3.3\,\text{cm}\).

Check the curved-face case by following the light. It enters through the flat face without bending, since the beam is parallel to the axis. The curved mirror, of radius \(10\,\text{cm}\), brings it towards a point \(5\,\text{cm}\) in front, inside the glass. Leaving through the flat face, that point appears at \(5/1.5 = 3.3\,\text{cm}\), the apparent depth. The formula and the tracing agree.

ExampleAn object before a silvered lens

An object stands \(15\,\text{cm}\) in front of the plano-convex lens silvered on its flat face (\(f = -10\,\text{cm}\) as a mirror). Find the image.

Reveal one step at a time and finish the rest yourself.
Checkpoint · numericUnanswered

An equiconvex glass lens of focal length \(20\,\text{cm}\), with both radii \(20\,\text{cm}\), is silvered on one face. Find the focal length of the equivalent mirror, as a size in cm.

cm± 2 %
CheckpointUnanswered

A plano-concave lens of focal length \(-20\,\text{cm}\) is silvered on its flat face. What does it behave as?

Cut lenses

Cutting a lens

The focal length of a lens depends only on the curvatures of its two faces and on its glass. So ask one question of every cut: does each piece keep both faces? Fig 5.3 shows an equiconvex lens of \(20\,\text{cm}\) cut two ways.

Cutting a convex lens two waysThree drawings side by side. On the left, an equiconvex lens of focal length 20 cm, with two dashed lines: A along the principal axis and B across the lens through its middle. In the middle, the two halves cut along A, pulled a little apart: each half still has both curved faces and a focal length of 20 cm. On the right, the two pieces cut along B, pulled a little apart: each is plano-convex, with one flat face, and has a focal length of 40 cm. A B f = 20 cm along A along B each f = 20 cm each f = 40 cm
Fig 5.3An equiconvex lens of focal length \(20\,\text{cm}\). Cut along A, the principal axis, each half keeps both curved faces: \(f = 20\,\text{cm}\). Cut along B, across the middle, each piece is plano-convex: \(f = 40\,\text{cm}\).

Cut along the axis, each half still has both curved faces, with the same radii. The lens maker's formula gives the same \(f = 20\,\text{cm}\). Only the aperture is halved. One half gathers half the light, so its image is complete but half as bright. Now pull the two halves slightly apart, across the axis. Each half has its own optical centre, so a point object gives two images, one from each half.

Cut across the middle, each piece keeps one curved face and gains a flat one. It is a plano-convex lens: \(\dfrac{1}{f} = 0.5 \times \dfrac{1}{20}\), so \(f = 40\,\text{cm}\). Put the two pieces back in contact, either way round. Two lenses of \(40\,\text{cm}\) in contact give \(\dfrac{1}{F} = \dfrac{1}{40} + \dfrac{1}{40}\), and \(F = 20\,\text{cm}\) again.

CheckpointUnanswered

The lower half of a converging lens is covered with black paper. What happens to the image of a candle on a screen?

Exam traps
  1. Adding focal lengths instead of powers.
    For lenses in contact, add \(1/f\), or add the powers in dioptres. Then take the reciprocal.
  2. Counting the lens once in a silvered lens.
    The light passes through the lens on its way in and again on its way out, so \(P = 2P_L + P_M\).
  3. Thinking any cut halves the focal length, or doubles it.
    A cut along the axis leaves both faces, so \(f\) is unchanged. A cut across replaces a curved face by a flat one, so each piece has twice the focal length.