doPhysics.in
All chapters
Pressure in Fluids · Lesson 5 of 6

Liquids in Accelerating Vessels

15 min read4 ideas6 checks1 figure to playBy Asheshanand Acharya
What you will learn 0 / 4
Pressure gradient in an accelerating fluid
Look around
The tanker that brakes

A water tanker on a busy road brakes hard at a signal. Inside the tank the water surges forward and piles up against the front wall, and the whole truck lurches. On a bus, a glass of tea on the dashboard does the same thing in miniature. While the bus brakes steadily, the tea stays tilted, higher at the front of the glass.

you will find the angle of the water's surface for any acceleration, and the depth of the water at each end of a tank.

A slab of liquid that accelerates

In a liquid at rest, the pressure grows downward at the rate \(\rho g\) and does not change along a level line. Now let the vessel accelerate with a steady horizontal acceleration \(a\). After a moment the liquid settles and moves with the vessel, so every part of it has the same acceleration \(a\). A horizontal slab of liquid then needs a net horizontal force. Only a difference of pressure between its ends can supply it.

Deriving \(\dfrac{\Delta P}{\Delta x} = -\rho a\) step 1 of 4
1

\[ m = \rho A\,\Delta x \]

Why. a horizontal cylinder of liquid of end area \(A\) and length \(\Delta x\), lying along the acceleration.

Vertically nothing has changed: the liquid does not accelerate up or down. So the pressure still grows downward at \(\rho g\), exactly as at rest. The pressure now changes in two directions. It grows downward at \(\rho g\) and backward at \(\rho a\), against the acceleration.

The effective gravity

The two rates can be put in one vector. The pressure gradient \(\nabla P\) points in the direction in which the pressure grows fastest, and its size is that rate. At rest \(\nabla P = \rho \vec g\), straight down. In the accelerating vessel, \(\nabla P = \rho(\vec g - \vec a)\). The liquid behaves exactly as if gravity were \(\vec g - \vec a\). This is the effective gravity.

RememberPressure in an accelerating liquid
\[ \nabla P = \rho\,(\vec g - \vec a), \qquad \vec g_{\text{eff}} = \vec g - \vec a \]
Holds whena liquid moving with its vessel, every part with the same acceleration \(\vec a\); \(\vec g\) points down.
Symbols\(\nabla P\) pressure gradient (direction and rate of fastest growth of pressure), \(\rho\) density, \(\vec g\) acceleration due to gravity, \(\vec a\) acceleration of the vessel, \(\vec g_{\text{eff}}\) effective gravity
Units\(\nabla P\) in Pa/m, accelerations in m/s²

The same result comes from the vessel's frame. In the chapter on Accelerated Objects, a body in a frame with acceleration \(\vec a\) felt a pseudo force \(-m\vec a\). In the vessel's frame, each bit of liquid feels its weight \(m\vec g\) and the pseudo force \(-m\vec a\). Together they are \(m(\vec g - \vec a)\), a weight in the effective gravity. The liquid is at rest in this frame, so every rule of the last lessons holds with \(\vec g_{\text{eff}}\) in place of \(\vec g\).

principle 1.3
Effective gravity

A liquid that moves with a vessel of acceleration \(\vec a\) behaves as a liquid at rest in a gravity \(\vec g - \vec a\). Its pressure grows along \(\vec g - \vec a\) at the rate \(\rho|\vec g - \vec a|\). Its surfaces of equal pressure, the free surface among them, are at right angles to \(\vec g - \vec a\).

Tilted surface of an accelerating tank
Maths you need

The tilted surface

The free surface is at one pressure, the atmosphere's. So it must be at right angles to \(\vec g - \vec a\). For a horizontal acceleration \(a\), the effective gravity points down and backward, at an angle \(\theta\) to the vertical with \(\tan\theta = a/g\). The surface tilts by the same angle \(\theta\) from the horizontal. It rises towards the rear.

A tank of water that acceleratesA tank 2 metres long, holding water 1 metre deep, rides on a wheeled platform that accelerates to the right. A slider sets the acceleration a from 0 to 10 metres per second squared. The free surface tilts about its middle to an angle theta with tan theta = a/g, so the water stands deeper at the rear and shallower at the front: at 5 metres per second squared, 1.5 metres at the rear and 0.5 metre at the front. Inside the water, the effective gravity g minus a is drawn with its two parts, and the surface stays perpendicular to it. geff g −a geff a rear 1.50 m front 0.50 m tan θ = a/g = 0.50, θ = 26.6°
SimA tank \(2\,\text{m}\) long, holding water \(1\,\text{m}\) deep, rides on a platform that accelerates to the right. Move the slider. The surface tilts to \(\tan\theta = a/g\), at right angles to \(\vec g_{\text{eff}}\), whose parts \(\vec g\) and \(-\vec a\) are drawn beside the tank. At \(10\,\text{m/s}^2\) the front of the base is just bare.

The same angle comes from pressure alone. Take two points at the same level near the base, a distance \(L\) apart: A at the rear and B at the front. Horizontally, \(P_A - P_B = \rho a L\), from the derivation above. Vertically, each point is at \(P_0\) plus \(\rho g\) times the depth of water above it. So \(\rho g (h_A - h_B) = \rho a L\), and \((h_A - h_B)/L = a/g\). The difference in depth over the length is the slope, \(\tan\theta\).

RememberSurface of a liquid with horizontal acceleration
\[ \tan\theta = \dfrac{a}{g}, \qquad h_{\text{rear}} - h_{\text{front}} = \dfrac{aL}{g} \]
Holds whena liquid moving with its vessel at a steady horizontal acceleration \(a\); the surface is a plane, higher at the rear.
Symbols\(\theta\) angle of the free surface with the horizontal, \(a\) acceleration, \(g\) acceleration due to gravity, \(L\) horizontal distance between the two points, \(h\) depth of liquid at each point
Units\(a\) and \(g\) in m/s², lengths in m
ExampleA tank on an accelerating cart

A tank \(2\,\text{m}\) long on a cart holds water \(1\,\text{m}\) deep. The cart accelerates at \(5\,\text{m/s}^2\). Take \(g = 10\,\text{m/s}^2\). Find the angle of the surface, the depth at each end, and the difference in pressure between the ends at the level of the base.

Reveal one step at a time and finish the rest yourself.

Now the braking tanker of the opening. Braking is an acceleration backward, so the "rear" is now the front of the truck. Suppose the tanker brakes at \(2\,\text{m/s}^2\), with water \(1\,\text{m}\) deep in a tank \(6\,\text{m}\) long. Then \(\tan\theta = 0.2\), about \(11°\). The water rises \(3 \times 0.2 = 0.6\,\text{m}\) at the front, to \(1.6\,\text{m}\), and falls to \(0.4\,\text{m}\) at the back.

Checkpoint · numericUnanswered

An open tank \(2\,\text{m}\) long and \(1.4\,\text{m}\) tall holds water \(1\,\text{m}\) deep. Take \(g = 10\,\text{m/s}^2\). What is the largest horizontal acceleration, in m/s², before the water spills over the rear wall?

m/s²± 2 %
CheckpointUnanswered

A closed box, partly filled with water, slides freely down a smooth incline of \(30°\). How does the water's surface lie while the box slides?

Bucket in a lift

A bucket in a lift

Let the acceleration be vertical, as in a lift. Take upward as positive. For an upward acceleration \(a\), \(\vec g - \vec a\) points down with size \(g + a\). So the pressure at a depth \(h\) in a bucket of water is \(P_0 + \rho (g + a) h\). For a downward acceleration, \(a\) is negative, and the pressure is smaller. The surface stays level, since \(\vec g - \vec a\) is still vertical.

Predict firstLocked

A tub holds water \(1\,\text{m}\) deep in a lift. At rest, the gauge pressure at its bottom is \(10\,000\,\text{Pa}\). The cable breaks, and the lift falls freely. What is the gauge pressure at the bottom now?

A tub of water in a liftA tub holding water 1 metre deep stands on the floor of a lift. Chips set the lift at rest, accelerating up at 2 metres per second squared, accelerating down at 2 metres per second squared, or falling freely. The water behaves as if gravity were g plus a: the gauge pressure at the bottom of the tub is 10 000, 12 000, 8000 and 0 pascals, and in free fall the water presses on nothing.elevator car (open front) geff geff = 10 m/s² P − P0 = 10 000 Pa

The chips of the figure above step through the cases for water \(1\,\text{m}\) deep. With the lift accelerating up at \(2\,\text{m/s}^2\), \(g_{\text{eff}} = 12\,\text{m/s}^2\) and the gauge pressure is \(12\,000\,\text{Pa}\). Accelerating down at \(2\,\text{m/s}^2\), it is \(8000\,\text{Pa}\). In free fall it is zero, exactly as a weighing scale in a falling lift reads zero.

Checkpoint · numericUnanswered

A lift accelerates upward at \(5\,\text{m/s}^2\). Take \(g = 10\,\text{m/s}^2\). What is the gauge pressure \(40\,\text{cm}\) below the surface of the water in a bucket in the lift, in Pa?

Pa± 2 %
U tube accelerated along its arms

A U-tube that accelerates

Fix a U-tube of water on a trolley, with its vertical arms a distance \(L\) apart along the direction of motion. When the trolley accelerates at \(a\), the liquid in the horizontal bottom limb must accelerate with it. That needs a pressure \(\rho a L\) larger at the rear end of the limb than at the front. Only a taller column in the rear arm can supply it. So \(\rho g\,\Delta h = \rho a L\), and \(\Delta h = aL/g\).

A U-tube on an accelerating trolleyA U-tube of water with vertical arms 30 centimetres apart is fixed on a trolley. At rest the two levels are equal. When the trolley accelerates to the right, the water stands higher in the rear arm, by a times L over g: 6 centimetres at 2 metres per second squared and 15 centimetres at 5 metres per second squared. The water in the bottom limb needs a forward push, and only a taller column at the rear can give it.flat trolley / laboratory cart 30 cm Δh = aL/g = 0.0 cm
Fig 5.1A U-tube of water with arms \(30\,\text{cm}\) apart on a trolley. Choose a chip. At rest the levels are equal. Accelerating at \(2\,\text{m/s}^2\), the rear arm stands \(6\,\text{cm}\) higher; at \(5\,\text{m/s}^2\), \(15\,\text{cm}\) higher.

The two surfaces in Fig 5.1 are two points of one tilted surface. The line joining them slopes at \(\tan\theta = a/g\), exactly as in the tank. This makes the U-tube an accelerometer: measure \(\Delta h\) and \(L\), and \(a = g\,\Delta h/L\). For arms \(30\,\text{cm}\) apart at \(2\,\text{m/s}^2\), \(\Delta h = 2 \times 30/10 = 6\,\text{cm}\).

Checkpoint · numericUnanswered

A U-tube of water with vertical arms \(40\,\text{cm}\) apart is fixed in a car, along its length. The car accelerates at \(2.5\,\text{m/s}^2\). Take \(g = 10\,\text{m/s}^2\). What is the difference between the water levels, in cm?

cm± 2 %
CheckpointUnanswered

The U-tube of Fig 5.1 is on a trolley moving to the right at a steady \(3\,\text{m/s}\). Which arm stands higher?

Intuition

The pendulum in an accelerating car, from the chapter on Accelerated Objects, hung back at \(\tan\theta = a/g\). The liquid surface tilts by the same angle for the same reason. The string of the pendulum lines up with \(\vec g - \vec a\), and the liquid's surface lies at right angles to it.

In the world
Why tankers have walls inside

A tanker carrying a liquid is divided inside by walls with holes, called baffles. Without them, the whole load surges forward when the driver brakes and back when he speeds up. The surge pushes the truck and can tip it on a turn. The baffles split the liquid into short compartments, so each surge is small.

Exam traps
  1. Letting the surface rise at the front of a tank that speeds up.
    The water stays behind as the tank speeds up. It rises at the rear, at right angles to \(\vec g - \vec a\).
  2. Using the velocity in place of the acceleration.
    Only acceleration tilts a surface. At steady velocity the liquid is as at rest.
  3. Writing \(g - a\) for a lift accelerating upward.
    With upward positive, \(g_{\text{eff}} = g + a\). Upward acceleration raises the pressure; downward lowers it.
  4. Using the whole length for the rise at one end of a tank.
    The surface turns about its middle, so each end changes by \((L/2)\tan\theta\).