doPhysics.in
All chapters

Decay of Current and the Opened Switch

12 min read4 ideas6 checks1 figure to playBy Asheshanand Acharya
What you will learn 0 / 4
Decay of current
Maths you need

Taking the cell away

Let a steady current \(I_0 = E/R\) flow in an LR circuit. Now throw a switch that takes the cell out and closes the loop with a plain wire. With no cell, nothing drives the current, yet the current cannot stop at once. The inductor's back emf now pushes the current along, and the current dies away gradually. This is the decay of current.

Deriving \(I = I_0 e^{-t/\tau}\) step 1 of 4
1

\[ 0 = IR + L\dfrac{dI}{dt} \]

Why. the loop equation with no cell.

RememberDecay of current in an LR circuit
\[ I = I_0\,e^{-t/\tau}, \qquad \tau = \dfrac{L}{R} \]
Holds whenan inductor carrying \(I_0\) at \(t = 0\), closed through a total resistance \(R\) with no source in the loop.
Symbols\(I\) current at time \(t\), \(I_0\) current at the start of the decay, \(\tau\) time constant
Units\(I\) in A, \(\tau\) in s when \(L\) is in H and \(R\) in Ω
Decay of current in an LR circuitA 2 henry inductor has carried a steady 3 amperes through a resistor from a 12 volt cell. At t = 0.3 second the switch is thrown from a to b: the cell drops out and a plain wire closes the loop. The current does not stop at once; it keeps its direction and dies away, I = 3 e to the minus t over tau. The dashed tangent at the start reaches zero at t = tau, where the current is 0.37 of its first value. Now the coil drives the current, so its top end is negative. The second chip changes the resistor to 8 ohms at the moment of switching: the decay is twice as fast.12 V a b R = 4 Ω 2 H 0.511.522.53123Ot (s)I (A) τ steady: I = 3.00 A VR = 12.0 V, VL = 0.0 V
Fig 6.1A \(2\,\text{H}\) inductor has carried a steady \(3\,\text{A}\) from a \(12\,\text{V}\) cell through \(4\,\Omega\). At \(t = 0.3\,\text{s}\) the switch is thrown from a to b. Press play. The current keeps its direction and dies away. The dashed tangent at the start reaches zero at \(\tau\). The second chip changes the resistor to \(8\,\Omega\) at the moment of switching.

Follow Fig 6.1. The current keeps flowing the same way round, through the same resistor, and falls smoothly. Now the inductor is driving the current, so it acts as the source of the loop. Its polarity has reversed: the end where the current enters is now the negative one. With \(8\,\Omega\) in the loop, the time constant is \(2/8 = 0.25\,\text{s}\), and the decay is twice as fast.

ExampleThree amperes dying away

A \(2\,\text{H}\) inductor carries \(3\,\text{A}\) through a \(4\,\Omega\) resistor when the cell is replaced by a wire. Find (a) the current at \(0.5\,\text{s}\) and at \(1\,\text{s}\), (b) the time for the current to fall to \(10\,\%\), and (c) the total heat produced.

Try it on paper first. The solution is one tap away when you are ready.

The heat equals the stored energy exactly. The resistor turns \(I^2R\) into heat at every instant, and the store falls by just that much. So a larger resistance spends the same \(9\,\text{J}\), only faster. With \(8\,\Omega\) the current is gone in half the time, but the heat is still \(9\,\text{J}\).

Checkpoint · numericUnanswered

A \(0.4\,\text{H}\) coil carrying \(2\,\text{A}\) is closed through a total resistance of \(8\,\Omega\), with no cell. What is the current \(0.1\,\text{s}\) later, in amperes?

A± 2 %
Checkpoint · numericUnanswered

How much heat does the resistor of the last check produce while the current dies away completely, in joules?

J± 2 %
Checkpoint · tap in orderUnanswered

A current decays in an LR circuit with time constant \(\tau\). Put these moments in order, earliest first.

The tangent at t zero meets tau
Maths you need

Reading \(\tau\) off a graph

The decay curve starts steeply and then flattens. Its slope at the start is \(dI/dt = -I_0/\tau\). A straight line with that slope, drawn from \(I_0\), would reach zero after exactly \(\tau\). So draw the tangent at \(t = 0\), and where it meets the time axis, read off the time constant. It is the dashed line in Fig 6.1.

Deriving \(t = \tau\) step 1 of 3
1

\[ \dfrac{dI}{dt} = -\dfrac{I_0}{\tau}\,e^{-t/\tau} \]

Why. differentiate \(I = I_0e^{-t/\tau}\).

In the example the tangent starts at \(3\,\text{A}\) with a slope of \(-3/0.5 = -6\,\text{A/s}\). It meets the axis at \(0.5\,\text{s}\). The growth curve has the same property, as the last lesson showed: its tangent at \(t = 0\) reaches the final current at \(t = \tau\).

CheckpointUnanswered

On the graph of a decaying current, the tangent at \(t = 0\) meets the time axis at \(40\,\text{ms}\). The circuit has \(R = 5\,\Omega\). What is its inductance?

Opening the switch with a parallel path

Opening the switch on the two-branch circuit

Go back to the cell, \(R_1\), and the inductor in parallel with \(R_2\), all at \(4\,\Omega\), \(12\,\text{V}\) and \(2\,\text{H}\). After the switch has been closed a long time, the inductor carries \(3\,\text{A}\) and \(R_2\) carries nothing. Now the switch is opened.

Predict firstLocked

Just after the switch opens, what current flows through \(R_2\)?

Opening the switch: the inductor's current turns through R2The same circuit after the currents have settled: 3 amperes flow through the inductor and none through R2. At t = 0.5 second the switch K opens and the cell drops out. The inductor's current cannot stop at once, so the full 3 amperes turn through R2, upward, the opposite way to its current while the switch was closing. For an instant R2 has 12 volts across it. The current then dies away with a time constant of L over R2, 0.5 second.12 V R1 = 4 Ω L R2 K 123123−1−2−3Ot (s)current (A) IL IR2 IL = 3.00 A, IR2 = 0.00 A from the cell: 3.00 A

The inductor's current cannot change in an instant, so its \(3\,\text{A}\) goes on flowing down through it. With the cell's branch open, the only way back is up through \(R_2\). So \(R_2\) suddenly carries \(3\,\text{A}\), opposite to its current while the switch was closing. For an instant it has \(3\times4 = 12\,\text{V}\) across it. The current then dies away round the loop of \(L\) and \(R_2\), with \(\tau = L/R_2 = 2/4 = 0.5\,\text{s}\).

Without \(R_2\) the inductor's current would have no path at all. It would then be forced to zero almost at once, and the back emf would strike a spark across the switch. The parallel path lets the current, and the stored energy, die away gently.

In the world
The diode across a relay coil

A relay is a switch worked by a small electromagnet, and one clicks inside a home inverter when the mains fails. When the transistor feeding its coil switches off, the coil's current has nowhere to go. Its back emf could reach hundreds of volts and destroy the transistor. So a diode is wired across the coil, pointing so that it carries no current while the coil is fed. At switch-off it gives the coil's current a parallel path, and the current dies away through it, as through \(R_2\) above.

Why the current cannot jump
Maths you need

The current changes smoothly, the voltage need not

Every result of these two lessons rests on one rule. The current through an inductor cannot jump. A jump would mean an infinite \(dI/dt\), and so an infinite back emf \(L\,dI/dt\), which no source can supply. The stored energy \(\tfrac12 LI^2\) cannot jump either, for the same reason.

The voltage across an inductor has no such limit. At switch-on in the last lesson, \(V_L\) jumped from \(0\) to \(E\). In the circuit above, the voltage across the inductor jumped to \(12\,\text{V}\) with its polarity reversed. When you meet a switched circuit, first ask what current each inductor carried just before. The same currents flow just after.

CheckpointUnanswered

A switch operates in a circuit that contains an inductor. Which quantity cannot change suddenly at that instant?

Exam traps
  1. Letting the current stop the instant the cell is removed.
    The inductor keeps it flowing in the same direction, and it dies away as \(I_0e^{-t/\tau}\).
  2. Keeping the growth formula for a decay.
    With no source in the loop, \(I = I_0e^{-t/\tau}\); it starts at \(I_0\) and falls towards zero.
  3. Thinking a larger resistance releases less heat.
    The heat is always \(\tfrac12 LI_0^2\). A larger resistance releases it faster.
  4. Assuming a resistor's current keeps its direction when a switch opens.
    Only the inductor's current is fixed. A resistor in parallel with it may carry that current the other way.